About 50 or so of Pittsburgh’s leading capitalists – bankers, businessmen, past and future members of Congress – including such notables as Henry Frick, Andrew Carnegie and Andrew Mellon, were in need of recreation. They liked their privacy, so they gladly signed up when Frick talked them into forming the South Fork Fishing and Hunting Club in the mountains about fifty miles east of Pittsburgh.
The location featured a scenic reservoir, a dilapidated dam and plenty of room to build cottages on the shore or back in the surrounding woods. A fish trap on the spillway to keep the lake from losing stock improved the sport and it was no problem lowering and widening the top of the dam to accommodate a road. It was the perfect retreat for a weary millionaire.
Everything was peachy until the last day of May in 1889. That was the day after an unusually heavy rainstorm had arrived from the midwest and it rained all night. The manager of the club awoke to find the reservoir swollen, the water nearly cresting the dam. He quickly collected a crew to clear the now-broken fish trap – full of debris – from the spillway and another group to dig a new spillway at the other end of the dam. He also sent a messenger to the nearest telegraph office to alert officials in the town below the dam.
Later, when all his efforts proved useless, he sent someone again to the telegraph office to dictate an even more urgent message to the town. But in both cases, those on the receiving end decided it was another false alarm – there was often worry about the dam, but nothing had ever happened.
At 3:10 in the afternoon, the dam broke. 20 million gallons of water from Lake Conemaugh Reservoir drained in 40 minutes and coursed down the Little Conemaugh River headed for the city of Johnstown, Pennsylvania.
On the way it destroyed a village of some 30 houses, leaving only a single rock standing. It paused at a train viaduct, took about seven minutes to destroy it and proceeded with renewed fury.
By then, the torrent was so full of debris that the water was barely visible. A witness said it looked like ‘a huge hill rolling over and over.’
A train engineer saw it coming and raced toward the town with the whistle tied down to warn residents and some were able to get to high ground. The engineer survived after the flood picked up the locomotive and tossed it aside, but 25 passengers died.
There are more terrifying details about the Johnston Flood here, but in the end 2,209 people died, making it the worst loss of civilian life in the history of the country. It is now third, after the Galveston Hurricane and 9/11.
An attempt to recover compensation from the South Fork Fishing and Hunting Club failed, the courts deciding that the club as a whole could not be sued and the individual members not negligent. It was, as usual, an act of God.
But a little-known precedent from British common law began to get some attention and gradually states adopted legislation based on Rylands v. Fletcher, in which the courts had held that a non-negligent defendant could be held responsible for damage caused by unnatural use of land – it was the beginning of the field of liability law.
Johnstown has had floods since then, the most recent in 1976. Their solution is the Incline, which hauls everybody to the top of a hill.


























